Chris Khalil's Musings

My thoughts on work and life

The new digital ethnographer’s toolkit: capturing the participant’s lifestream

I’m pleased to say that my proposed presentation for UX Australia 09 has been accepted.  It looks like this is going to be any exciting conference and I look forward to making my maiden trip to Canberra.   The speaker lineup looks great and good to see fellow NDM UX USiT team members Patrick Kennedy and Stephen Cox also made the cut.

The abstract has yet to be posted to the UX Australia 09 site, but here is my prelimenary description

Introduction

The talk will explain what the ‘new ethnographer’s toolkit’ is, and how it can be used to reconstruct user behaviour and thus enable better informed design decisions.

A great user experience is grounded in the insights gained from understanding users’ needs, behaviours and motivations.  One powerful way of gaining this insight is by simply observing users in their natural environment, often over a long period of time by means of ethnographic research.  However, this isn’t always possible, due to factors such as a lack of time or resource.  In these circumstances, a good alternative is to use a Cultural Probe.  A Cultural Probe often, simply, takes the form of a paper diary that the participant uses on a daily basis to record their thoughts.

In this talk, Christopher Khalil of News Digital Media (NDM) will explain how NDM are using an innovative web/mobile based approach to Cultural Probes (digital scrapbooks) and other research tools, utilising an array of low cost and freely available web and mobile applications such as Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook and Dial2Do.  He’ll step through a specific case study based on one of Australia’s largest transactional websites, taking the audience through some of the lessons learnt and giving examples of some of the actual digital scrapbooks generated.  Advice will be offered on how to analyse and mine such rich resources of information.

Full Abstract

Digital cultural probes give participants the platform with which to capture events in their lifestream, whilst they happen, and also offer a self-reporting diary/blog tool. (Instead of the traditional, more asynchronous, method of filling out a paper diary at the end of the day).  This ‘as live’ capture ensures a more realistic, natural record of the participant’s life than asking them to fill out a diary entry alone.  Furthermore, it closely connects the researcher to the participant, since the researcher can also monitor updates to the probe as they happen.  Having a digital only record also facilitates easier analysis, versioning and distribution

An example of this type of study might start with the researcher recruiting a participant straight from the site they are working on (using Ethnio).  The participant is then issued with a login to a Tumblelog (a special form of blog) and is asked to use this to record anything they find interesting on the web during the next week. A special property of the Tumblelog is that it offers a very simple mechanism for the user to capture videos, emails, images, text, audio and IM conversations as they engage in their normal online behaviour.  It also facilitates simple aggregation allowing the Tumblelog to integrate other feeds such as their Twitter or Flickr streams.  The participant can then, optionally, add commentary around any of the items they log or posts they make.  In this way, the researcher is capturing the participant’s digital fingerprints, in the form of a digital scrapbook or diary.

Away from recording their online life, the participant can capture events on their mobile phone via voice recordings, SMS, MMS or email.  These are all sent to the single Tumblelog, giving the researcher an unprecedentedly rich tapestry of contextual, in situ information about the participant.  NDM are using this knowledge to improve the user experience around several major online presences.  Christopher will take the audience through real life case studies, making available some of these digital scrapbooks and illustrating how powerful their use is, and offering advice on how to analyse and mine such rich resources

digital ethnographers toolkit

digital ethnographers toolkit

Background

Paper or Video diaries and other traditional forms of Cultural Probe are not ideal, because they are largely asynchronous (from real life) and self referential (i.e. I talk about my day through a frame I think is important).  For example, in a traditional probe, the participant would go about their everyday life, and then at the end of the day reflect back on the significant events that have taken place.  The issue with this is that the minutiae and richness of the everyday (despite being potentially important) is often lost in the edited and processed view the participant takes in their diary entry.

In this talk we look at ways technology can help capture many of these moments, recording events in the participant’s lifestream as they happen using mobile and web applications.  In other words we are capturing their digital fingerprints. The advantage of this approach is that the recording mechanism is often in the same medium and context the researcher is trying to find out more about (the web).

These tools allow the participants to easily capture videos/photos/text snippets/instant message conversations/emails/audio etc they have found interesting and put some commentary around them.  This lifestream data can then be used as a form of moodboard/scrapbook, giving the participant the ability at the end of the day to look back on what they have recorded and make sense of it.

Since many researchers don’t have time or money to setup bespoke solutions or understand technical details, this study focuses on products which are largely free or inexpensive and which can be easily configured and setup by even by the less technologically savvy researchers.

3 Comments

  1. this sounds really interesting Chris! Can’t wait to see your preso 🙂

  2. This looks great Chris, cant wait to see the presentation. Awesome to hear about the kinds of methods you guys are using and developing, especially in this emerging area.

    While social technologies pose all sorts of new challenges for us as designers and researchers, they also present real opportunities as you demonstrate. I have also used MMS and blogging tools for design research with very rich results and the potential of these kinds of design methods to facilitate participation in design is at the core of my Phd research.

    When using social technologies as a way of investigating the use of social technologies, there is a relationship between the research medium and the subject of the research that isn’t present with more traditional methods of inquiry like interviews, focus groups or even cultural probes. As you put it Chris “the recording mechanism is often in the same medium and context the researcher is trying to find out more about (the web).”

    This relationship creates new opportunities for people to participate in design (or codesign). In my experience these kinds of methods not only generate rich data but can also act as a seeding activity for online engagement, and the data becomes something much richer, including potential “content”. In fact the practices of design, research and use start to blur.

    Some of the other interesting issues that get raised in this context for me are questions about ownership and privacy e.g who owns the content that is generated, what does it mean to use third party platforms that we don’t control, and what are our ethical obligations to our participants. Keeping research private and participants anonymous is not necessarily the appropriate approach in such a context, so what kinds of relationships do we need to broker with our “participants”, particularly in this public sphere. If you’re able it would be great to hear more about how you guys tackle those aspects too. (Excited about UXAustralia already! 🙂

    Thanks
    Penny

  3. Chris – this paper looks fabulous. I will be very interested to see your examples and the way you are presenting some of the material to generate new ideas, and bring designers closer to the lived experiences of their users.

    I love that you are harnessing the power of existing tools, especially ones that are easy for researchers to use. It would seem there are a few developers keen to patent their own ‘spaces’ – which often overlook the power of mobile phone blogging. I completely agree with you (and Penny) that the immediacy of real time uploads, allowing researchers to tune into peoples lives as they move through their day are far more powerful than relying on participants getting onto their computer and having to upload different files/media to a specific (not their usual) space.

    One thing you have not mentioned – but I imagine is possibly also true and check in with your participants – is just how much they enjoy the process and engage with the activity. (As opposed to a rigid & static homework task like a diary – that they fill out perhaps on day 7!) We have found it’s not only fun for them, it can also lead to some powerful self reflection – participants tune into their own rhythms and notice things about their lives they would not have the chance to without the ‘intervention’. Particularly powerful when applying the technique to social change type activities.

    Nice work!
    Now to check out Tumblelog …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*